[SydPhil] JSI Seminar: Nicole Vincent

Kevin Walton kevin.walton at sydney.edu.au
Mon Nov 5 10:53:39 AEDT 2012

Dear all

The next Julius Stone Institute of Jurisprudence seminar will take place at 6pm on Thursday 8 November. Nicole Vincent from Macquarie University will deliver a paper entitled "Restoring Responsibility: Promoting Justice, Therapy and Reform through Direct Brain Interventions". You are very welcome to attend. See below for further information. You can register here<http://sydney.edu.au/news/law/457.html?eventcategoryid=40&eventid=9838>.

Best wishes,

6pm Thursday 8 November
Dr Nicole Vincent
Restoring Responsibility: Promoting Justice, Therapy and Reform Through Direct Brain Interventions

Direct brain intervention based mental capacity restoration techniques-for instance, psycho-active drugs-are sometimes used in criminal cases to promote the aims of justice. For instance, they might be used to restore a person's competence to stand trial in order to assess the degree of their responsibility for what they did, or to restore their competence for punishment so that we can hold them responsible for it. Some also suggest that such interventions might be used for therapy or reform in criminal legal contexts-i.e. to make non-responsible and irresponsible people more responsible. However, in this paper, Nicole Vincent argues that such interventions may at least sometimes fail to promote these responsibility-related legal aims. This is because responsibility hinges on other factors than just what mental capacities a person has-in particular, it also hinges on such things as authenticity, personal identity, and mental capacity ownership-and some ways of restoring mental capacity may adversely affect these other factors. Put one way, Vincent's claim is that what might suffice for the restoration of competence need not necessarily suffice for the restoration of responsibility, or, put another way, that although responsibility indeed tracks mental capacity it may not always track restored mental capacities.

Nicole Vincent conducts research into theories of responsibility, and she studies how these theories inform ethical, political and legal debate. In 2007, she obtained her PhD in philosophy of law from the University of Adelaide with a dissertation entitled "Responsibility, Compensation and Accident Law Reform<http://bit.ly/caBne5>". From late 2007 until early 2011 she worked at Delft University of Technology in The Netherlands on a research project entitled "The Brain and The Law<http://bit.ly/bNc4Qd>". Since February 2011, Nicole has been a Macquarie University Research Fellow. Her research project entitled "Reappraising the Capacitarian Foundation of Neurolaw<http://bit.ly/aziP5j>" has two components. First, it investigates whether capacitarian intuitions about the relationship between mental capacity and responsibility still obtain in contexts where mental capacity has been restored or enhanced. Second, she is also, with others, developing an Australasian Neurolaw Database.


Sydney Law School | Julius Stone Institute of Jurisprudence

T +61 2 9351 0286  | F +61 2 9351 0200
E kevin.walton at sydney.edu.au<mailto:firstname.surname at sydney.edu.au>  | W http://sydney.edu.au<http://sydney.edu.au/>

This email plus any attachments to it are confidential. Any unauthorised use is strictly prohibited. If you receive this email in error, please delete it and any attachments.

Please think of our environment and only print this e-mail if necessary.

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://mailman.sydney.edu.au/pipermail/sydphil/attachments/20121104/2d2c864a/attachment-0002.html>

More information about the SydPhil mailing list